The Soapbox

Joined: 08/13/1998 Posts: 21280
Likes: 14841

What's this?

Yes. Interesting but with four flaws in his argument.

First, our current state of hyper-partisanship would infect the lottery. Sure, Alabama might do better than Tuberville with a random selection, but maybe that's what you'd get or worse.

Second, new and untested people break unstated rules than maintain order. They also are unfamiliar with the levers of power that can be used to get things done.

Third, if we trusted democracy, we wouldn't have the electoral college.

Fourth, do we include the court system?

(In response to this post by 111Balz)

Posted: 08/22/2023 at 07:47AM

PREV NEXT REPLY

Insert a Link

Enter the title of the link here:

Enter the full web address of the link here -- include the "http://" part:

Current Thread:

NYT: elections are bad for democracy -- MasterRusty 08/22/2023 06:43AM

When are you rightwing dumbfucks going to realize that an oped column ... -- HowieT3 08/22/2023 09:22AM

Hoo chooses the opinion pieces? ** -- MasterRusty 08/25/2023 10:01AM

Choosing an opinion piece for the oped page doesn't necessarily mean ... -- HowieT3 08/25/2023 10:30AM

OK, so Rusty's headline is (more than) misleading. How about the -- Late 80s Hokie 08/22/2023 10:32AM

The 12th of Never. They are almost always fact free, so what's left? -- Chuck Taylor 08/22/2023 10:19AM

When they attain an 8th grade reading level. But....that seems -- Shenhoo 08/22/2023 09:32AM

That's why we like the McPaper (U.S.A. Today) It is written at an eighth -- Tuckahokie 08/22/2023 09:35AM

The left has been playing the Reichstag fire game to push for their own -- HokieDan95 08/22/2023 08:53AM

😂 Someone really needs to stop reading the nonsense incel trolls and bots -- WahooRQ 08/22/2023 09:30AM

Talk about derangement syndromes. This was a completely apolitical -- hoolstoptheheels 08/22/2023 09:20AM

Apparently I am a robot. (I can't get past the captcha.) Good to know! ** -- Faz d. Hoo 08/22/2023 08:41AM

I mentioned this possibility couple of times before. i think at certain -- JohnHoo2 08/22/2023 08:36AM

This was my concern as well when I've considered this (sort of) random -- Late 80s Hokie 08/22/2023 09:37AM

The only experience that seems to matter is how to best game the system for -- Hooooooooooooooo 08/22/2023 11:57AM

This is one reason I'm somewhat against term limit. In old chinese -- JohnHoo2 08/22/2023 10:32AM

How frequently do you think elected pols really manage the complexity of -- hoolstoptheheels 08/22/2023 08:47AM

The notion that we should gut the civil service, which many GOPers embrace -- CMUHoo 08/22/2023 09:33AM

MAGA is anti-expertise. Makes them feel ignorant. Can’t have that. ** -- SixerHoo 08/22/2023 10:14AM

The subject of Michael Lewis’ “The Fifth Risk”. -- hoolstoptheheels 08/22/2023 10:05AM

Hadn't seen that book somehow, but just the blurb rings true -- CMUHoo 08/22/2023 10:26AM

As I said yesterday on the Corner before the thread got daisy cut... -- Faz d. Hoo 08/22/2023 09:02AM

What went down on the Corner? -- Shenhoo 08/22/2023 09:22AM

Hawaii ** -- Faz d. Hoo 08/22/2023 09:32AM

Wasn't so passive based on my skim through -- CMUHoo 08/22/2023 09:30AM

Yeah pushing the the theory that people died because some -- 111Balz 08/22/2023 10:29AM

Link not working for me/safari. ** -- HokieDelNorte 08/22/2023 08:27AM

I’m a fan of Adam Grant - he wrote “Think Again”, which should be required -- hoolstoptheheels 08/22/2023 08:14AM

That’s one of the best things you’ve ever posted although I disagree with -- 111Balz 08/22/2023 07:19AM

I wonder if the age of social media discourages some potentially good -- Tuckahokie 08/22/2023 08:06AM

Take it a step further - I think you’re describing the way things work now. -- hoolstoptheheels 08/22/2023 09:09AM

Not quite sure I see how that would happen. -- hoolstoptheheels 08/22/2023 08:43AM

Yes. Interesting but with four flaws in his argument. -- DanTheFan 08/22/2023 07:47AM

I think Grant himself provides the answer to implementation in his piece. -- hoolstoptheheels 08/22/2023 08:38AM

My biggest fear, that at least, in some places people of bad intent -- 111Balz 08/22/2023 08:50AM

Lord knows it would provide a spectrum of people who are not, -- hoolstoptheheels 08/22/2023 08:59AM

Yes and I appreciate that perspective on human psychology but I also -- 111Balz 08/22/2023 09:28AM

It’s radical, I agree. So, I think we’d have to see the results with other -- hoolstoptheheels 08/22/2023 10:02AM

When I first heard of this idea about 10 years ago, I thought it couldn't -- JohnHoo2 08/22/2023 10:38AM