The Soapbox

Joined: 09/29/2013 Posts: 60863
Likes: 57514

What's this?

The whole TX and ID approach is just weird to me, and well above my legal

understanding. IIRC it had something to do with being necessary to survive initial scrutiny (and the article I linked below said ID thinks they can hold up better by making legal challenges easier than TX did), but that all along they were hoping some of the other cases would be the ones to actually make a change in Roe (MO maybe). So it's almost as if they never intended these laws to actually survive.

But in the meantime, even if it's just legal wrangling, I think it's going to hurt them, and probably badly. Even just on the surface, I don't think your average voter is going to think 6 weeks is anywhere close to reasonable, so if they don't even go past that aspect, I have to think a bunch of voters will simply stop at "well I'm not voting for the folks pushing that".

(In response to this post by hoolstoptheheels)

Posted: 03/16/2022 at 5:12PM

PREV NEXT REPLY

Insert a Link

Enter the title of the link here:

Enter the full web address of the link here -- include the "http://" part:

Current Thread:

Congrats Idaho. Rapists family members can sue the victim if she has an -- HooAskedYou 03/16/2022 4:22PM

Certifiably insane ** -- HokieJamie 03/16/2022 5:44PM

I think the vast majority of Americans would agree that the snitch model -- Capital City Hoo 03/16/2022 5:20PM

MAGAts aren’t rational human beings ** -- WaxHoo 03/16/2022 5:35PM

The key is, that states are allowing citizens to sue for LEGAL behavior.The -- 81_Hokie 03/16/2022 5:30PM

That'll be easy for this SCOTUS. The second amendment is in the -- Seattle .Hoo 03/16/2022 5:34PM

Is that amendment the one guaranteeing RWNJ women the right to bear -- TomGlansAski 03/16/2022 5:39PM

This is how the secret police operated in places like East Germany and -- TomGlansAski 03/16/2022 5:28PM

That was SOP behind the Iron Curtain. ** -- NJHoo 03/16/2022 5:40PM

Socialism on 'roids ** -- Tuckahokie 03/16/2022 5:42PM

Authoritarianism on steroids, I think you meant. Whatever version of -- Shenhoo 03/16/2022 6:06PM

Concur...some may like the snitch laws with which they agree, but not all -- Tuckahokie 03/16/2022 5:28PM

Expect some states to do that as well has pass laws to defend themselves -- Seattle .Hoo 03/16/2022 5:23PM

Idaho…providing RWNJ incels and proudboys everywhere with -- TomGlansAski 03/16/2022 5:19PM

Isn't that already the rule in Texas? ** -- HoosWillWin 03/16/2022 5:14PM

The Taliban says WTF! ** -- 757 03/16/2022 4:39PM

Let’s see if these vigilante laws survive judicial review. ** -- hoolstoptheheels 03/16/2022 4:31PM

SCOTUS sez weren’t you watching? ** -- WaxHoo 03/16/2022 5:23PM

Technically it's not even a law yet since the Gov hasn't signed it yet to -- Hoodafan 03/16/2022 4:57PM

I agree with your last paragraph, but if Roe goes down shortly, -- hoolstoptheheels 03/16/2022 5:05PM

This SC is not consistent -- Zhoo 03/16/2022 5:22PM

And fails to enforce laws on the books. Like voting rights. ** -- Seattle .Hoo 03/16/2022 5:29PM

I linked an article about a certain SC who voted on way for -- Zhoo 03/16/2022 6:12PM

The whole TX and ID approach is just weird to me, and well above my legal -- Hoodafan 03/16/2022 5:12PM

The law is just designed to make it more risky -- KCHoo 03/16/2022 5:17PM

They want these laws to get challenged and end up before the SCOTUS too. ** -- WahooRQ 03/16/2022 7:41PM

Good point. And in the meantime, piss off a ton of voters unfortunately IMO ** -- Hoodafan 03/16/2022 5:28PM

One can only hope. But I think you are out of touch with how brainwashed -- TomGlansAski 03/16/2022 5:44PM

Idaho voters will go to WA and OR for healthcare. ** -- Seattle .Hoo 03/16/2022 5:21PM

Well, they already have to go to those places for culture -- southdenverhoo 03/16/2022 7:23PM

Any of the unvaxxed mouthbreathers who had Covid should have been turned -- TomGlansAski 03/16/2022 5:34PM

Or follow the lead of one of our posters and head north to make Canadian -- Hoodafan 03/16/2022 5:29PM

The next step will be to make that illegal ** -- Zhoo 03/16/2022 5:24PM

Which begs the question....how can Idaho law be enforced in Washington? ** -- Seattle .Hoo 03/16/2022 5:26PM

I actually think overturning Roe, if it happens, has a good chance of -- hoolstoptheheels 03/16/2022 5:15PM

I agree. The gop may regret that victory. ** -- BocaHoo91 03/16/2022 5:35PM

Oh that absolutely benefits the Dems. The most active and engaged single -- Hoodafan 03/16/2022 5:27PM

I stand corrected on one point, so my apology to HooAskedYou this go around -- Hoodafan 03/16/2022 5:05PM

Should have been stopped months ago but Scotus let them continue. What BS ** -- 81_Hokie 03/16/2022 4:41PM

Yep and Texas courts have been ruling based on what they EXPECT SCOTUS to -- Seattle .Hoo 03/16/2022 5:20PM

Texas indicates they will (at lease the GOP versions of them) ** -- WahooMatt05 03/16/2022 4:41PM

Texas is predicting the outcome in the Supreme Court? -- hoolstoptheheels 03/16/2022 4:43PM

Sorry, SCOTUS allowing Texas to survive as it has indicates it -- WahooMatt05 03/16/2022 4:48PM

I’m not enough of a legal eagle to know if that means the SC -- hoolstoptheheels 03/16/2022 5:06PM